Offer comparison · US employment

A target bonus is a scenario, not a second salary.

An offer with the larger total at target can still have the smaller fixed salary. Read the salary and annual bonus separately before deciding which number to rely on.

Fictional example · USD before tax

Two offers, two different cash profiles

Offer A

$120,000

stated annual base salary

Annual bonus target
15% of base = $18,000
Base + full target
$138,000

Offer B

$130,000

stated annual base salary

Annual bonus target
5% of base = $6,500
Base + full target
$136,500

Assume continuous employment for one full modeled year, unchanged base pay, full bonus eligibility and no proration. Each target uses the stated annual base as its denominator. Assume any modeled bonus is earned and paid in that year. These are invented offers, not market data or an employer’s plan.

Sensitivity check · not a forecast

The ranking changes with the bonus assumption

Modeled annual cash = annual base + (annual base × target percentage × fraction of target paid). To isolate the effect, each scenario uses the same fraction of target for both offers. Real plans can have different outcomes; these three points are not probabilities, a payout range or a cap.

0% of each target

Offer A
$120,000
Offer B
$130,000

B has $10,000 more modeled cash.

50% of each target

Offer A
$129,000
Offer B
$133,250

B has $4,250 more modeled cash.

100% of each target

Offer A
$138,000
Offer B
$136,500

A has $1,500 more modeled cash.

At 50%: A = $120,000 + ($18,000 × 0.5) = $129,000.
B = $130,000 + ($6,500 × 0.5) = $133,250.

If one plan pays 0% and the other 100%, compare those separately rather than forcing both onto the same row. No taxes, equity, signing bonus, benefits, overtime, raises or repayment terms are valued here. An annual earned amount also does not tell you when money reaches your account.

Confirm the plan before relying on the target

  1. What is the denominator? Ask whether the percentage uses annual salary, eligible earnings or another amount, and which plan year applies.
  2. What determines the payment? Request the written plan: individual and company measures, discretion, thresholds, caps and who approves the result. Keep unknown terms marked “not confirmed.”
  3. When do eligibility and payment start? Confirm joining-date rules, proration, the payment date and any requirement to remain employed then.
  4. What does payout history actually describe? Ask which years, roles and employee group a quoted figure covers. Past payments do not guarantee your result.
“Could you share the annual bonus plan and confirm the target calculation, my first-year eligibility, the conditions for payment and its expected date? I am comparing base salary separately from variable pay.”

This is an example question to adapt, not a message sent by OfferBrief. If a bonus is described as guaranteed, request its written amount and conditions rather than assuming it matches the target.

Source, arithmetic and limits

The US Department of Labor’s Fact Sheet #56C (December 2019; consulted November 11, 2026) explains bonus treatment in the regular rate for non-exempt employees. It cautions that a “discretionary” label alone does not decide the legal classification. That overtime rule is a different question from how much this fictional comparison pays; this guide does not classify your bonus or determine a legal entitlement.

All amounts above are editorial arithmetic from the invented inputs, not DOL wage estimates, payout evidence or take-home pay. For a disputed promise or legal classification, seek qualified advice with the actual documents.